Sunday, July 26, 2015

Journal Entry #4 -- July 26, 2015

Yesterday and today my wife were primarily involved in hauling everything out of our son's room to then prep and repaint it.  He's ten years old and shouldn't have to sleep in a room we designed for a baby.
Painting and home improvement are not my particular areas of expertise.  The knowledge I gain doesn't so much make me effective as it makes me dangerous.

When applied to my teaching practice, how much of this phenomenon, of knowledge making me dangerous, happen?
Just because I know to spackle over nail holes and then sand the surface once it's dry doesn't mean I'm going to know that I should indent the first coat of spackle, sand that, and then reapply spackle and sand a second time.  Where have I improperly spackled as a teacher because I knew enough to spackle but not enough to do it with the experience-based expertise of a true professional?  I came to teaching via NJ Alternate Route in 2002.  I had a music performance degree and got a 10-month course in Gardner's intelligences, classroom management, planning, and behavioral issues.

At the conclusion of that, and the satisfactory completion of Praxis, the State of New Jersey officially declared me a professional.

The kind of professional who still needed to find out from hard won experience to spackle, indent, sand, spackle again and sand, metaphorically speaking.

Friday, July 24, 2015

Journal Entry #3 -- July 24, 2015

It pains me to finish a project for another course -- an extensive description and explanation of a proposed classroom practice relating to temperament and learning style -- and strongly suspect it stands little chance of actually being effective were it to be carried out.
But due dates and obligations are what they are. I keep trying to remind myself it's the honest attempt that's important. A due date is a due date and I have many more academic and non-academic obligations to which I must attend.
It's hard to know I'm about to put something out into the universe that I've already decided just wouldn't be successful in its application.

Wednesday, July 22, 2015

Journal Entry #2 -- July 22, 2015

In class yesterday, a distinction was drawn between Quantitative and Qualitative research.
Under the Qualitiative column, we identified the following:
This kind of research begins with a hypothesis.
The researcher may ask, is it generalizeable?
Does it have internal validity?
Is it observable? Measurable? Replicable?

Under the Quantitative column, we identified the following:
Instead of a hypothesis, a question is explored.
The researcher seeks recognizeability and/or relatability in the phoenomenon observed (speaking specifically about teacher research wherein a teacher researches/reflects on his/her own practice).
The additional term I'd include here, because I like it, is resonance.

Does the researcher establish trustworthiness of observations made?

Are the practices observed revealed to have catalytic authenticity, i.e. does it create something that changes lives for the better?

What did I take from this?
What we traditionally recognize as research (Quanitative) leads to clear answers and data.  This is the activity of science.
This other thread of exploration we do not traditionally recognize as research (Qualitative) and can generate more questions without conclusively answering any.
The product of this enterprise yields some insight that we recognize as true, and we relate to it.  The insight resonates with us.
This is the activity of art.

So, if the act of teaching and reflecting/researching our teaching follows this more qualtitative thread, what we're doing is art, and we are artists.

I think one of the problems in earning the same kind of recognized legitimacy for the teaching profession that medicine or law enjoys, is that we are artists trying to earn legitimacy playing by science's (or academia's at any rate) rules.  This is because science has more societal value in the Western world than art does.  Science prepares young minds for College and Careers -- what does Art prepare them for?


This is what we're up against.
----------------------------------------------

Other random thoughts I had during class yesterday:

In the education marketplace of ideas, do we want, or can we afford, to allow WalMart and Target to drive out the Mom and Pop stores?
Speaking of which, look at this dystopian nightmare which is unfortunately actually a real thing I just found: https://seattleducation2010.wordpress.com/2015/07/22/kipp-and-the-behavior-modification-of-teachers/

The cord to the pendulum ball might have snapped (this to those who "hope the pendulum will swing back").

Teachers to professional superiors & those outside the profession: "Let me show you how my teaching works."

Students to teachers: "Let us show you how we learn."

Profession of nursing comes up against medical science much like teaching comes up against higher academia.  This is the clash of art vs. science.

Is the problem of defining teacher research the problem of trying to make art play by science's rules?
(My big question of the day)

It's no wonder we don't fare well in an art-hostile environment.

Danielson: Be Reflective™

Part of our problem is simply the symptoms of bureaucracy.

Let's capture lightning in a bottle!  Best practices imposed on all (Good luck with that).

Chapter 1 of Inside/Outside says teacher research is "systematic and intentional inquiry carried out by teachers."  Why systematic and what system? Who decides?

Today's topic is important.  No one needs to make that case to me.  As a community we need to make that case to the public at large.  Reflecting on my practice has been intuitive to me since day one as a teacher.  I've gotten a whole lot better in thirteen years and reflection is why.

Seems to me the real reason to undertake this as an academic exercise is to legitimize what we do by giving it academic language.  Do doctors and lawyers undertake reflective practice and self-research as continued academic development?  Does academia expect that of them?  I don't know, I'm asking.


Monday, July 20, 2015

Journal Entry #1 -- July 20, 2015

Monday, July 20, 2015

In my EDUC 510 class on teacher research, which met for the first time today, our instructor informed us that we would be making regular journal entries during the course of our study.  

I figured it's the 21st century now, and what we do is blog.  It's easier to read, I can always find it, and no writer's cramp!  With that, welcome to my obscure EDUC 510 journal blog.

Today focused on an introduction to the concept of teacher research vis a vis some journaling prompts in class and an activity where we each had to ask questions of a fellow student.  The result of that exercise said much about the kinds of subjectivity we bring to any interaction -- how do we choose our questions, how do we interpret answers, how deeply do we probe on a given topic, etc.

I think subjectivity is part of the public relations problem from which our profession currently suffers.  No one can define good teaching the way you might define good auctioneering or good furniture manufacturing or even good medical care.  I'd venture to suggest there's far less subjectivity in the question of what is a good sandwich or a good cup of coffee than in what is good teaching.

Two of our journal prompts today dealt with describing the worst teacher we experienced and the best teacher we experienced.  What I took from that exercise, and probably others too, is that somewhere, I may be and probably am on somebody's "worst" list and someone else's "best" list.  I have not ministered to all students equally well or served all needs fairly.

My note for this in my chicken scratched "journal ideas for later" read, "I am on a great teacher and a bad teacher list: parallel universes of teacher influence."

Other random (or not so random) things I thought today:

I have done what I admire and what I despise.

A former student from many years ago passed, I learned this morning.  I am heartbroken by the news and touched that her friend (also a former student of mine) thought to reach out to me.

I never daydreamed about growing up to tell kids to stop daydreaming.

I spend too much of my professional energy reacting to propaganda (specifically "teachers are lazy and untrustworthy" propaganda legislated into educational mandates).


This job will never get easier.  Only harder.

Hello, & a quick word about the web address

Hi, this is my blog I am starting for use as a journal for one of my graduate education courses, a course in teacher research I started today.  I chose the handle "subversivecompliance" not because I am subversively complying to the journal requirement, but that I am alluding to my personal doctrine of subversively complying to certain legally mandated portions of my job as a public school teacher.  I don't believe that SGOs are even remotely valid measures of any teacher, and even though I am fortunate to fall on the "good side" of those figures, I feel morally compelled to at least speak up about their unfairness.  Same with No Child Left Untested and Race To The Bottom yearly testing mandates. I'd bore you with it in words but maybe it will save time to just drop a link here.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pwKqHHpARmE

With that, I give you my humble blog.

Andy